Independent Sanibel Captiva Island hotels

"We really enjoyed our stay at this place. Clean, modern and quiet with great accommodations. Awesome location right on the beach with easy access. We hope to come back soon and spend more time exploring the island. We will definitely stay at this condo when we return. "

"The Bayside Villa was a wonderful stay, very clean and spacious. Huge bed! A comfortable location in South Seas, would definitely book again. Host was informative and easy to work with."

"Stayed for 5 nights and would pick this place again. Right on the beach in a quiet area. The room was spacious and spotless. Appreciated the big shower. Pool area looked nice although I didn't use it as the weather was a little cool for the pool. Very courteous staff. "

"Everything was great! Clean, comfy and convenient to so many things! Only one suggestion. Add a bigger pan - cooking pasta was a challenge!Thanks for a great stay."

"Room was clean and was cleaned in the middle of our stay and staff was great."

"We were looking for a quiet place to stay. The Tarpon Tale Inn checked off every single box! From the welcoming text to the friendly Inn keeper, our stay was perfect. The room was clean and nice in size. The location was perfect! Just a quick bike ride (which were free of charge) to the beach. There were some cute shops next door and across the street. If we decide to stay on Sanibel Island again, we will be staying there!!"

"Everything was wonderful."

"Clean rooms, great staff, beautiful view "

"Clean, loved being right on the beach and the pool was great, the lanai was really nice…had to request a hair dryer, and one day I had to call to get the room cleaned by later in the afternoon. I thought $4 for a cup of coffee in the lobby while we were checking in after a full day of travel was a bit greedy especially because we paid a resort fee on top of a not cheap room rate. That could have and should have been complimentary. Bar food was great outside. Was here years ago, much upgraded and will definitely come again. "