Kelleys Island Caddy Shack Square Hotels

"Very nice and clean room. They had golf carts to rent at the property which was awesome and affordable! We didn’t use the pool but did use the hot tub which was also nice! We went on some hikes and had some good food at one of the local bars. We would stay again for sure. "

"The cottage was clean and neat. Furniture was NOT garage sale quality! We loved the seclusion and amenities were a quick drive. At first I questioned having to bring our own bed linens and towels but then understood with the water situation. I can understand the stress of a washer and dryer. This home away from home is a bargain!"

"Didn’t get access codes as promised. Had to call their office en route to facility. Also no toilet paper. Otherwise it was very nice stay."

"Wonderful location and it’s a beautiful condo. All rooms were very clean and Corrie was helpful and responsive. "

"Beautiful property. I am surprised with the low stars on Google. I have worked at Hilton and Marriot properties for years as a GM and DR of sales. Anyways, if you are expecting that type of hospitality at this property you won't get it. I think that's what is charming about this place. The front desk clerk was super nice. The people who work there are focused on their jobs and aren't there to make you feel like you are on vacation, that's what the island is for. I definitely recommend staying here. For our family of five it was fantastic. Rooms are roomy, pool is clean and it's a great location. We can walk right into town, walk to the beach and have dinner right across the street. I definitely recommend staying here. "

"We could not check-in until Friday due to the ferry not running Thursday. The kitchen had food left from an other renter."

"This is just the space we were looking for and everything was clean. Disappointed that the pool was clos.ed during our stay"

"Super Hot pool was great "

"It was just ok. Floors in room Were stained and not very clean. Outside was fine but pool want the cleanest. Could be more to do on the property besides just a pool. "