Ithaca Buttermilk Falls State Park Hotels

"Loved the original and period appropriate charm of the Grayhaven Motel. We were blown away by the thoughtful touches like complimentary smores kits and wood bundles and local granola for breakfast. Parking was a breeze and access to the state parks and Ithaca were immediate. Would definitely seek this place out again on future trips!"

"Place was clean, the staff extremely friendly and breakfast was pretty good for continental!!"

"Easy check in. Walking distance to Buttermilk Falls. Easy drive to downtown. Spacious room, nice staff, decent breakfast, clean areas."

"Stellar place! The staff was friendly and welcoming. Fast check-in and check-out. Safe and quiet. Clean and neat. Conveniently located near Ithaca College. Delicious, nutritious free breakfast with plenty of options. Good prices. Highly recommended!"

"Staff was friendly. We loved the front desk employee that checked us in. He was friendly, personable, and humorous. Excellent hospitality. I was very happy with the location and proximity to state parks. The building is a little outdated but not a concern. "

"Good value for price.All staff engaging, helpful and knowledgeable. Close to Buttermilk Falls and quick drive to downtown. free parking. "

"Nice price: thirty to fifty percent less than other motels in Ithaca, NY, last night. Room was clean, warm (very warm, which was very important because outside temperature was near zero) and dry. Desk clerk was a very pleasant, attractive, well-mannered Asian woman. "

"Friendly staff, clean room, great location and Ithaca is perfect!"

"Excellent service the restaurant was fabulous , five stars can’t wait to return!!!!!"

"great location to all wants and needs "

"Good location close to Ithaca Commons, walking distance to State Theater and many eateries."

"Excellent people - nice motel - HIGHLY RECOMMEND FOR YIUR STAY IN ITHACA, NY! Great location too!"

"As always, had an excellent stay here. Very convenient if you are visiting Cornell University or the amazing state parks nearby. Breakfast was good - waffles, eggs, sausages, bagels, fresh fruits etc. even our fur baby loved it here. Highly recommend this hotel. "

"Nice location. Great place to stop on way to Niagara Falls from NYC"

"It is a good, comparatively affordable option for a quick getaway to the Finger Lakes. While not centrally located it was an easy and short drive into Ithaca. "

"Don’t let the exterior detour you. If your looking for a comfortable and clean place to lay your head, this it! So budget friendly and all of the staff is so attentive. Even with my daughter’s food allergies. We will definitely stay here again for our next Cornell visit. Thank you for a restful stay!"

"A lovely place to stay for the weekend! Great kitchen - coffee, snacks, etc."

"Lovely and quaint. Short stroll into state park and lake!"

"Really loved this place. Very charming, beds were comfortable, water hot. Not always the case in a historic building. The pub that’s part of it is as great too. I missed breakfast but I heard that it was really good. A very nice weekend retreat. "

"This is a wonderful gem not far from Ithaca. Rose and Rachel are kind and personable. The room I had was spacious and relaxing. The breakfast was incredible. I truly enjoyed my stay and hope to return again!"