Independent Anna Maria Island hotels

"⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ We had a wonderful stay at Captain’s Quarters on Anna Maria Island! The location is perfect — close to the beach, shops, and great local restaurants — yet still peaceful and relaxing. The property was clean, comfortable, and thoughtfully set up with everything we needed for a stress-free stay. The atmosphere truly felt like a home away from home, and it was the perfect place to unwind and enjoy island life. We made so many great memories and appreciated how easy and enjoyable our stay was from start to finish. We would absolutely recommend Captain’s Quarters to anyone visiting Anna Maria Island and would love to stay here again! 🌴✨"

"The room was exactly as shown, plenty of room to stretch out and we especially loved the end unit. Steps from the beach and shelling was perfect! Grounds were raked each morning with umbrellas taken down each day. Nice cushions on the lounge chairs, deck furniture and the beach towels were nice & fluffy. A great lil refrigerator, we would have liked a coffee maker, rather than a cappuccino and the coffees offered were strong. No microwave. Bathroom with a lovely rain-head was favorable. We definitely recommend and it is located in a desirable area. "

"Room was spotless. Location right at the beach entrance on the corner. Terrific shops and food within walking and a short drive to Cortez too. "

"Loved it. Would definitely come back"

"Parking was extremely easy with our own spot, pool was clean, nice pool area. Staff was nice when checking in. Our place was nice, large and exactly what I expected from photos on website. We could walk anywhere we needed to go."

"Very good only problem was the WiFi very spotty "

"Room was clean and staff was friendly"

"I loved my stay !! Everything was perfect about it "

"This home is beautiful, and in a wonderful location. The pictures looked like the beach was more beach rather than rocky, but overall it was very amazing. We got to see a pod of dolphins swim by a couple times one day. It was a pleasure being able to use for the week "