Independent New Church hotels

"Key West Cottages were clean, quiet, comfortable and private. Loved the beautiful pastel colors and the landscaping- beautiful little private beach and pool. We’ll definitely return."

"Comfortable bed."

"Excellent and beautiful place to stay. The staff are very helpful in meeting your needs and making you feel welcome:)"

"The staff is very friendly and accommodating! Walkable to Island creamery. Short drive to the beach! Highly recommend this hotel!"

"The room was very fresh and felt like new. Everything was nice and comfortable. Pretty quiet location because the hotel isn't on the main street. Smooth check-in and check-out. "

"Tiny, but perfect for 2 people. The screened in porch was a huge bonus, we spent alot of time out there in the comfy hammock chairs without having to worry about bugs. The listing is misleading with the "water view" though. Its close to the water but theres a row of houses between that blocks the view. Overall great stay, easy check-in, quiet neighborhood. We would definitely come back"

"Wonderful hotel!! "

"Lovely view, clean, recently updated, comfortable bed. I would suggest improved pillows."

"I have stayed here several times and never disappointed. Room is comfortable with a nice view of the water. Very quiet. Breakfast is hot and packed up to take to the room or eat outside. Pool is clean and has late hours at night. "