City Island 4 Stars Hotels

"Good location"

"Booking a Hyatt Regency, I assumed that I would have the same room amenities as any other full service property. This was not the case at this hotel. At check in, the front desk clerk said that they had 24 hour staff to assist me. I noticed at 10pm that there wasn’t a coffee maker or tea device in the room. When I called the front desk they offered to bring a kettle and tea, but a kettle with no tea was delivered. I tried calling the front desk and received a voicemail twice. I requested they call me back and never received a follow up call. The hotel also lacks any room service. This is not a full service hotel, instead a limited service hotel like a Hampton Inn, but at least at a limited service hotel, the breakfast and coffee would be free. This hotel required payment for a cup of coffee or tea in their “cafe” in the lobby. Don’t be fooled by the brand. You’d be better off at a Red Roof Inn. "

"It was a pleasant stay "

"I had a great experience from check-in to check-out. Housekeeping was very polite and friendly. Every single staff member I interacted with was 10/10! I will definitely stay here again"

"It was a wonderful hotel. We even received an upgrade so we had a terrace. And on such a beautiful New York night, we had a great chill space after a full day/ night"

"Great property, staff and location!"

"Love their cookies"

"Great breakfast"

"."