Nutley 5 Stars Hotels

"Lovely stay"

"Great location with the metro, one world and many restaurants close by. "

"The hotel was lovely and had a house car to drop me off at a nearby dining area for brunch!"

"Staff and service were excellent "

"Beautiful hotel. Definitely recommend staying here if you’re traveling to this part of the city. Typical city traffic around the hotel. GPS was not helpful finding the front door. Drove around the block a couple times before we figured it out. Still, would definitely stay there again. "

"Great stay. Property in need of refurb"

"Need to improve elevator sutuation"

"The most elegant hotel. World-class service. Extraordinary experience. A MUST book!"

"Great place to relax and recover from a busy work life"

"Location"

"Perfect location. Luxurious room and good service. "

"Only two words for the Carlyle: THE BEST."

"Location "

"The quality of service, has deteriorated considerably especially in front desk. The restaurant service was never good in this hotel, starting from the two lady hosts in the morning, waiters who are far from caring, absolutely indifferent and unhappy people waiters ( one time they brought me another food, something I did not order ). On the other hand, they have an impeccable house keeping service. The hotel, rooms, location all are very very good. "

"The Plaza is of course iconic. The building is very old so not everything is spotless. Old curtains get stuck; light interruptors sometimes fail, etc. The staff is not the most friendly - they have some attitude. But if you show the money, you can have the time of your life. Still a great experience. "

"Noise from bar in lobby"

"Staff was amazing. From check in to check out, the front desk, doormen, and concierge were uniformly polite, friendly, and helpful. Only (very small) glitch was being seated by the kitchen for brunch. Our bad for not making reservations. Just seems that hotel guests should get better tables especially when many tables were empty. "

"Expensive but worth it. Two adults & 2 younger kids. We got a one bedroom suite that was HUGE. Most of the reasonably priced rooms in the city are the size of shoe boxes. NOTE: though they list that the room sleeps 4 , it doesn’t without rollaways. But the rooms are so big that the rollaways fit no problem. Bed was comfy. Room was quiet-never heard neighbors above, below, or to the sides. Usual NYC noise on the street at all hours but not bad with a white noise machine. Ask for a higher...

"Staff was friendly, room was comfortable and well-designed. "

"We can’t wait to stay here again! The staff was outstanding and the location for Broadway fans is perfect! The junior suite worked great for our family of 5. "